From Doubt to Certainty: Shaping a New You

If you’ve ever tried to talk yourself into confidence using affirmations like “I am powerful” or “I believe in myself”, only to feel like your nervous system isn’t quite buying it, you’re not alone.

Affirmations can be a beautiful tool. But when they don’t feel true yet, they can stir up more resistance than confidence. It’s not that you’re doing anything wrong, it’s just that your inner identity hasn’t caught up yet.

That’s where identity shifting comes in.

Real change doesn’t happen by repeating what we hope is true. It happens when we gradually become someone who believes those truths about ourselves… because we’ve lived them, practiced them, and found evidence for them.

This is how we make change stick. And it starts by understanding what identity actually is.

---

What Is Identity, Really?

Your identity isn’t a fixed fact. It’s a pattern, made up of experiences, meanings, and beliefs you’ve picked up over time. Most of them were formed unconsciously. And who we believe we are, dictates our behaviour.

If you believe you’re “not a confident person,” or “someone who never follows through,” it’s not because it’s written in stone, it’s because of past experiences, and more importantly, the meaning you gave them, that shaped that belief.

The good news? If your identity was learned, it can be reshaped.

You can grow beyond who you’ve believed yourself to be. But trying to change your entire identity overnight can feel overwhelming. That’s why we break it down, one quality at a time.

---

Qualities Create Identity

Think of the parts of your identity like individual traits you’ve built certainty around.

If you say “I’m a good friend,” or “I’m dependable,” it’s because you’ve gathered real-life evidence that supports that belief. You’ve embodied those qualities enough times that they feel solid within you.

But when it comes to qualities you want to embody (like courageous, grounded, or capable) you might feel uncertain. That’s where the work begins.

We shift identity by focusing on one of those qualities at a time, and building up evidence that we already embody it in small, real ways. The more we reinforce it, the more certain we feel. And the more that quality becomes part of who we are.

---

Why Affirmations Alone Often Don’t Work

When you repeat affirmations that don’t yet feel true, your system can go into resistance. Instead of creating alignment, it can create inner conflict.

It’s like your conscious mind is saying one thing, but your subconscious mind is shaking its head.

This isn’t about giving up affirmations altogether. It’s about backing them up with embodied evidence. Small actions, habits, and reflections that begin to shift your internal identity.

---

Start With One Quality

Instead of trying to overhaul your whole identity at once, begin with one quality you want to strengthen. Something you already value, but don’t fully believe you embody yet.

The first step isn’t to “become” it. It’s to notice where it’s already true.

We often focus on where a quality feels absent, but the real work is training your brain to see where it’s present. Even if it’s just a flicker.

• Want to feel more confident? Look for the times you have spoken up, even when it was hard.
• Want to be more grounded? Find the moments you’ve stayed steady in chaos, or comforted someone else.
• Want to feel more worthy? Reflect on when you honoured your needs, drew a boundary, or asked for support.

You’re not starting from zero. You’re gathering evidence that this quality already lives in you, and you’re building certainty around it.

The more often you remind yourself of those moments, big or small, the more naturally that quality becomes part of your identity. And from there, your actions begin to align.

This is how lasting identity shifts happen:
Not by forcing yourself to believe something new…
But by remembering what’s already true.

---

A Journal Prompt to Start Shifting

Now that you’ve explored how identity shifts happen one quality at a time, try this simple reflection to help you start the process:

1. Identify a goal or desire.
What’s something you want to create or move toward in your life?

2. Ask: “What’s stopping me?”
Write down the fears, doubts, or blocks that come up.

3. Dig deeper:
What would I have to believe about myself in order for those blocks to feel true?

4. Reconnect to your core values:
What do I prefer to believe that feels more aligned with the version of me I’m becoming?

5. Find the evidence:
Where can I already see that quality in myself, even in small ways?

This isn’t about forcing belief. It’s about remembering what’s already true and choosing to build on that, one quality at a time.

---

Final Thoughts

You don’t need to become someone else. You’re not broken or behind.

You’re simply being invited to remember who you already are underneath the old stories, the outdated patterns, and the false limitations.

Identity shifting isn’t about pretending. It’s about transformation.

And the more you bring certainty to the qualities that matter to you (the ones that already live inside you) the more you’ll move through life as the version of you who is already capable, already worthy, already ready.

One shift at a time.

---

Ready to step into the new version of you?

This is the kind of transformational work I do with my coaching clients. If you’re ready to create lasting change from the inside out, click here to apply to work together. I’d love to hear more about where you’re headed.